Unit 17 in New Mexico has sparked discussion among hunters, with many emphasizing its challenging terrain and varying elevations, which can impact the accessibility and movements during hunting seasons. Hunters have noted that draw odds are competitive, requiring strategic planning and flexibility. The unit is recognized for its elk population, but successful hunting often demands thorough scouting and an understanding of game behavior, particularly during rut. Overall, the consensus suggests that preparation and adaptability, coupled with local insight, significantly enhance the hunting experience in Unit 17.
Elk and antelope thrive in this unit, which includes the San Mateo and Magdalena mountain ranges. Apache Kid, Withington and Chupadera wilderness areas are entirely inside the unit, which also contains several hundred square miles of desert flatlands. Only bowhunters and muzzleloader hunters may hunt elk.
This is one of the finest elk hunting areas in New Mexico, with a healthy number of elk and many bulls getting old enough to grow impressive racks. This area has low deer densities and bucks struggle to reach maturity.